Meet Benny: former jock, secret gay icon, and king of overcompensating. This hit Prime Video comedy is a hilarious and honest look at the agony of the closet, the power of true friendship, and the messy, glorious journey of self-acceptance. If you’re looking for one of the most current and engaging gay-friendly sitcoms, this is it!
©Prime Video / Amazon MGM Studios
Short Intro
Overcompensating is a contemporary comedy-drama series for Prime Video, created by and starring social media comedian Benito Skinner. The show follows Benny Scanlon, a former high school football star, valedictorian, and homecoming king, who begins his first year of college as a deeply closeted gay man. His desperate attempt to “overcompensate” for his true feelings with hyper-macho behavior drives the early comedy, making it a fresh and honest addition to the world of gay-friendly sitcoms.
Note: If you like gay comedies, we recommend reading our articles about Schitt’s Creek.
Why You Should Watch It
A Raw Look at the Closet:
This series provides a humorous and sometimes embarrassing look at the challenges of being closeted about your identity. It’s an essential story about the journey of coming out and learning to accept who you are.
A Look at Identity:
The story addresses how young people shape their modern gay identity while navigating a confusing social landscape. Overcompensating uses humour to explore the pain and absurdity of trying to fit in, securing its place as a powerful voice among Gay-friendly sitcoms.
Sharp, Generational Humour:
Benito Skinner, a talented creator, delivers his unique sense of humor through engaging storytelling. His show is packed with clever jokes, playful adult humor, and references to popular culture, making it enjoyable for a wide range of viewers.
Public and Critical Reviews
The series has received a great response from critics, earning very high ratings. Many have described it as a “genuinely heartfelt, sweetly funny, and refreshingly bold” story. Viewers especially connected with the show, particularly those who have ever felt like they didn’t’ fit in during their college years. Reviewers pointed out that while the show is full of laughter and fun, it also has a deeper side, skillfully mixing wild adventures with essential themes about identity and self-acceptance. This blend of humor and heart is what makes it a favorite among gay-friendly sitcoms.
Where to Watch
Overcompensating (Season 1) is available to stream worldwide on Amazon Prime Video.
Conclusion
Overcompensating is a must-watch for anyone who has ever felt pressure to fit a mold. As one of the newer gay-friendly sitcoms to hit the mainstream, it’s an energetic, heartfelt reminder that the person you pretend to be is always less interesting than the person you truly are.
Take a look at

Boots on Netflix: A March Through Identity, Brotherhood, and Quiet Liberation
In this blog post, we will talk about Boots Series on Netflix, the latest LGBT+ sensation on this platform. Furthermore, we will reveal why it

The most appealing Amazon Prime Video Gay TV Series
Amazon has been increasing its share of the vibrant LGBT shows and series. Would you like to know which are the most appealing Amazon Prime

Our favorite LGBTQ+ holiday movies to watch this December
The Christmas holidays are knocking on our doors, and moviemakers are becoming more open to embracing queerness. In recent years, Yuletide has been queerified, with
References and sources:
Photo credits:
Prime Video / Amazon MGM Studios